If you’re scrolling through celebrity photos after Super Bowl weekend, two things usually happen. One, you find yourself judging the half-time show harder than the actual football game. And two, you definitely find some fashion choices that make you pause…and maybe tilt your head a little.
Super Bowl after-parties are a unique cultural moment. Celebrities arrive basked in glamor, ready to celebrate wins, losses, and the free bar. But sometimes they arrive in outfits that make us squint, laugh, or wonder.
We will walk you through a list of the worst-dressed celebs in Super Bowl after party history in this guide, so get your judgment glasses on.
1. Doja Cat’s Mesh-Over-Everything Moment
Source: Link
Doja Cat is known for her bold fashion risks. She’s embraced everything from sculptural couture to streetwear that borders on avant-garde. But at the Michael Rubin Fanatics Super Bowl Party back in 2022, something about her outfit just didn’t land. A sheer mesh dress that left little to the imagination, knee-high socks paired with chunky boots, a feather shawl that seemed to float in its own world, and oversized sunglasses that hid most of her face. Nothing about the entire look was cohesive. The execution looked like stylistic pieces fighting for attention rather than working together.
2. Coi Leray and the Ballet Slipper Debacle
Source: Link
At another Fanatics Super Bowl party in 2025, Coi Leray showed up and… well, let’s just say some looks make you think rather than ooh. Her outfit mixed a baby tee, micro shorts, bright blue tights, over-the-knee socks, and fuzzy ballet flats. Now, before you gasp, remember that fashion is often about contrast. But the combination of baby tee innocence with fuzzy footwear that felt more bedroom slipper than runway just didn’t mesh. We admire her for prioritizing comfort but there’s also a line between comfortable and confusing.
3. Martha Stewart: Farmer’s Market Casual
CC BY 3.0, Link
We have all shown up under-prepared for something we were expected to be dressed for. At the same 2025 Fanatics Super Bowl party, Martha Stewart arrived looking… cozy. And by cozy, we mean somewhere between running errands and heading to a casual brunch. Stewart wore what might have been perfectly fine for a farmers’ market visit, featuring tennis shoes, a relaxed outfit, and an overall laid-back vibe. There’s a fine line between “I don’t care what you think” and “I think I’m in the wrong place.”
4. Hayden Panettiere with Business Casual Time Capsule
CC BY-SA 2.0, Link
Flashback to 2013, when business casual gave a few people way too much confidence. Actor Hayden Panettiere walked into a Super Bowl party wearing leather leggings, bright orange platforms, and a blazer. Yes, a blazer. The intention was clearly to create an outfit that was both night-out and smart. But the result was more like “office party that got weird.” Ten years on, the outfit belongs in a style museum labeled “Time Capsule Err.”
From today’s fashion hits and misses to classic glamour, take a look back with these iconic photos of old Hollywood celebs who defined style in their era.
5. Melody Thornton and the Low-Rise Jeans Fiasco
Source: Link
Melody Thornton brought us a lesson in proportions that could have been great… if it just fit right. At the 2022 Sports Illustrated Super Bowl Party, Thornton paired a corset top with jeans that sat so low they created a bizarre silhouette that elongated her torso awkwardly. The corset and hairstyle were pretty solid. Thornton knows how to present a vibe. But the jeans… oh, the jeans. They clashed with her proportions in a way that distracted rather than enhanced.
6. Audrina Partridge Goes Full Latex
Source: Link
Some outfits are bold. Some are memorable. And some make you say, “That could have been something else.” Audrina Partridge attended a 2022 Super Bowl party in a look that mixed a brown latex-looking corset, royal blue leggings, and a coral jacket. Individually? Some of these pieces could have worked in a different setting. Together? They felt like a stylist threw three different vibes into a blender and hit “puree.” And, it didn’t work. Not to mention, we don’t know how comfortable wearing an all-latex outfit was.
7. Blu DeTiger Needed Better Tailoring
Source: Instagram
Sheer dresses are tricky. Done right, they’re ethereal and fashion-forward. Done wrong, they make you wonder if the tailor took a coffee break at the worst possible moment. Blu DeTiger hit that awkward space at the FanDuel Super Bowl Party in 2025. Her dress was definitely a statement, but it bunching around her waist gave it an unintended silhouette that distracted from the look. When a daring piece doesn’t fit properly, the eye gets caught in all the wrong places and that’s what necessarily happened in this instance.
8. Ice Spice with “Mix and Match”
CC BY 2.0, Link
Ice Spice sat close by Swift at the game, and her outfit ignited its own commentary. She paired an unbuttoned white button-up with lacy red undergarments and white denim shorts. While bold choices are part of her signature, a number of fans and critics felt the look didn’t harmonize with the event’s energy or with the outfits of those around her.
9. Brittany Mahomes, Featuring Glossy yet Cringey
CC BY 2.0, Link
Patrick Mahomes’ wife Brittany showed up in a bold all-white outfit that included a cropped denim jacket and jeans emblazoned with “Chiefs” down the leg. Critics, especially on social media, didn’t hold back. Many described the look as outdated, overly staged, or trying too hard for a game-day environment. The intention was definitely to stand out but let’s be honest, the outfit didn’t serve what it was supposed to.
10. Travis Kelce’s Retro Look
Source: Reddit
Travis Kelce himself wasn’t immune to fashion scrutiny. Before the 2025 Super Bowl kicked off, he arrived in a rust-colored suit that many fans compared to a 1970s throwback gone wrong, complete with wide collars and a retro vibe that fell flat for some viewers. Social commentary spun jokes comparing his look to characters out of a ’70s crime drama or a disco club.
Even stars who wowed crowds at Super Bowl after-parties often had humble starts—like celebrities who failed before making it big.
11. Jamie Hauptmann and her Pink Corset Top
If there’s one Super Bowl celeb outfit that will stay in your mind for decades, it is Jamie Hauptmann’s metallic pant and pink corset top. The combination of the bedazzled top and the shiny pants somehow left people in awe. But, that said, while her outfit was all types of weird, she surely flaunted her perfect physique. However, the outfit surely concealed a lot of her and also made her stance awkward.
Final Words
The worst-dressed moments in Super Bowl after-party history are not just fashion disasters. They are cultural snapshots. And honestly, that is part of the appeal. Perfectly styled looks fade quickly. The questionable ones linger in memory. Because if everyone played it safe at Super Bowl after-parties, we would have nothing to talk about once the game is over.
The post The Worst-Dressed Celebs in Super Bowl After-Party History appeared first on Oldest.org.